Methodist Church
Built in 1789 Commack's Methodist Church building is the oldest in New York state. It is also considered to be one of the best in way of original condition with very few alterations being done in over 200 years.
The only thing that has changed in the church parking lot is that the carriage sheds have been removed since automobiles replaced the horse and buggy
Unchanged in over 200 years the Methodist church is one of Commack's oldest buildings still standing today.
The site of the old parsonage was used to build a new modern church and school. The road is also much wider today then it was some 80 years ago.
The Methodist parsonage was built in 1886 south of the church next to the Brynt house.  Across the road on the bend was Rankin's dairy farm.